Includes evaluation of the movie vs book pairing with several options. Apr 11, 2017 comparing frankenstein s monster in mary shelleys 1818 novel to the 1931 universal movie. Differences and similarities differences and similarities are used to emphasize certain aspects of things. Had i no self control, this answer would be the length of another novel. Nov 21, 2019 one of the notable changes form the novel in the 12minute film is a happy ending for frankenstein and his new wife, elizabeth spoiler alert. It creates an atmosphere of tension for the readeraudience. Shelley began writing the novel in 1816 while summering in geneva with lord byron and percy shelley. From the very beginning of the film the differences are numerous victor frankenstein s name isnt victor in the movie its henry. P 5 comparative study of frankenstein novel and movie. Frankenstein is a famous horror novel written by mary shelley.
Frankenstein in the novelization of the screenplay that was written for the yetunmade film which, at one time, was to reunite young sherlock holmes nicholas rowe and alex cox as holmes and watson. In the book the victors father was a businessman and in the movie the father was a doctor, which was pretty different but it was not a dramatic difference. Frankenstein adaptations are almost never frankenstein. The 1931 black and white film of frankenstein has very few similarities to the original story written by mary shelley. The details as to how victor creates the creatures body parts are left unknown. It seems like he is followed or even hunted by his. All clips property of their respective owners, used for the purposes of a. A bigger difference was that in the book alphonso frankenstein, victor. According to wikipedia, the film is more different than it is similar. What are differences between frankenstein book and the movie. Frankenstein s life involves elizabeth a lot more in the film, and he brings her back to life at the end. The monster was mute, although he did say friend once or. In the case of frankenstein, i believe this would be another example of that claim. I would love to see hollywood create a film following the books narrative.
Novelmovie difference mary shelleys frankenstein essay. What are the essential differences between the frankenstein. The film tells the story of a doctor augustus phillips who creates a monster charles ogle and soon learns to regret it. A comparison of differences and similarities in frankenstein. Horror stories are designed to entertain people by causing enjoyable feelings of. The frankenstein film community note includes chapterbychapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and quizzes written by community members like you.
There are various differences in plot points, characterization, thematic points, and even the ending. In search of the most authentic frankenstein movie penguin books. Examine the difference between the original novel and two movies from the 1930s in this lesson. During his stay at the university he constructs and reanimates an 8. Mary shelleys frankenstein book vs movie add a difference.
The process of creating the creature is different in the two stories. Frankenstein 1910 out of 4 historic adaptation of the famous novel from edison was considered lost for decades but thankfully a print now two prints was discovered to be in pretty good condition. While use of movies in the classroom can be controversial, bringing different media into. Unlike the previously covered sherlock, this film doesnt so much update to present day as craft a whole new. Differences between mary shelleys frankenstein book vs. Gardi department of english, maharaja krishnakumarsinhji bhavnagar university, bhavnagar. Dec 18, 2017 had i no self control, this answer would be the length of another novel.
This is because, the movie is mainly based on the 1920s play, other than the original mary shellys book frankenstein. Similarities include character, mood, and plot, though even within these there are numerous differences. Frankenstein is a murderer, while the monster is violent and dangerous from the moment of his creation. In shelleys novel, as well as the 1931 film frankenstein, the doctor is about to. Book frankenstein by mary shelley has been reproduced many times in the form of both book and film.
In the book, the creature acts savagely because of the way he was treated. And i will try to keep them free of strong opinions. The director of the movie may choose to keep details in his movie that adheres to the details in the book that the m. With patrick bergin, randy quaid, john mills, lambert wilson. A comparison of the book and the movie frankenstein the context in which a text is placed changes its purpose and allows it to be interpreted in a variety of ways. After the vision of the film frankenstein of mary shelley directed by kenneth branagh 1994 and the reading of the novel frankenstein. Though the movie is about frankenstein s grandson, the differences with the appearance of the monster, the relationship between creator and creation, and the creation of the monster are very different from the novel.
Best frankenstein film that was closest to the mary. During his stay at the university he constructs and reanimates an 8 foot tall ugly creature. A comparison of film and novel versions of frankenstein essay. Why is the 1994 film version of frankenstein so different from shelleys novel frankenstein. In the book, the abomination taught himself to read, write and talk. Victor discovers the secret to creating life after examining the deceased professor waldmans research. Frankenstein s life involves elizabeth a lot more in the film.
This article is a compare and contrast essay between frankenstein novel vs. None of these films even remotely followed the original novels storyline, and none ever achieved the kind of fame garnered by the original movie. Amongst other major plot changes, the monster is cloned from frankenstein. Oct 06, 2011 the 1910 film frankenstein was the first motion picture adaptation and therefore had some similarities and differences to the novel. The basis for differences between mary shelleys frankenstein book and james whales 1931 movieli the plot structure in the book vs the movie. Compare and contrast frankenstein book and movie essay. A comparison of film and novel versions of frankenstein the nature of horror stories gives the readeraudience a feeling of intense fear, shock or disgust. The most recent version starring kenneth branagh, who also directed it, and robert deniro has many differences when compared to the original story. Why is the 1994 film version of frankenstein so different.
How is the original frankenstein movie 1931 different. In shelleys novel frankenstein s monster had got his head cut because of frankenstein s need to put the brain in his creation, not by an axe. Film what do you think about the frankenstein novel and movies. The basis for differences between mary shelleys frankenstein book and james whales 1931 movie li. In the original novel, the monster was designed to be beautiful and was alert, fast, strong, and. Comparison between the film and the book frankenstein. Novelmovie difference mary shelleys frankenstein essay bartleby. The film version of frankenstein switches the names of the characters victor and henry from the book, so that victor frankenstein in shelleys novel becomes henry frankenstein in whales film, and henry clerval in the novel becomes victor moritz onscreen. Frankenstein by mary shelley has been reproduced many times in the form of both book and film. Summary of differences between the movie frankenstein 1994 and the book unsorted movie. Difference in details of bringing the monster to life.
Comparative study of frankenstein novel and movie 1994 submitted to. In the film, frankensteins assistant also absent in original novel steals a brain to use for the monster. It was produced by martin scorsese and based on dean koontzs version of frankenstein. Frankenstein and his monster have been portrayed in a book and in movies. Frankenstein is a 2004 madefortelevision usa network production starring thomas kretschmann as victor helios supposedly the man that the fictional character victor frankenstein was based on and vincent perez as his creature. Wasnt the last batman movie based upon this theme where batman devised plans to incapacitate all justice league members in case they ever.
P 5 comparative study of frankenstein novel and movie 1994. A comparison of film and novel versions of frankenstein. The question and answer section for frankenstein film is a great resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss the novel. The function, perspective and audience of the novel frankenstein by mary shelly differs greatly to the film mary shelleys frankenstein by kenneth branagh in many ways.
What are differences between frankenstein book and the. There are many minor details which are different from the in the book and movie. The events of the novel are in fact prefilm, and all covered in the first five minutes. In reading the book mary shelleys frankenstein, and watching the by the same title, i discovered several large differences.
Listing five differences from mary shelleys frankenstein novel and its film adaptations. Mar 12, 2019 touching on themes of ambition, lost of innocence, revenge, humanity, responsibility and creattion, frankenstein is a dense but very worthwhile classic of its genre. Mar 14, 2014 p 5 comparative study of frankenstein novel and movie 1994 1. There are more differences than similarities between the book and the movie. Shelley, mary frankenstein, the novel and the film. The curse of frankenstein is more a horror movie than it is an adaptation of shelleys novel. Frankenstein essay there is little doubt that frankenstein is one of the most wellknown and most celebrated stories in history. The source text for multiple film, book, and stage adaptations, mary shelleys frankenstein combines the bonechilling imagery of the gothic novel with the romantic eras exploration of the sublime in order to grapple with the question of what hides within human nature. Victor frankenstein 2015 the movie vs the screenplay. For the sake of my sanity, i will limit the differences to the essential. There are two versions of the book, the originally published in 1818 and then a revised version that was published in 1831. It was later adapted into a movie version directed by james whales. However, it unfortunately has been largely displaced in the popular consciousness by its film adaptations. Frankenstein the novel is the old testament to i, frankensteins new.
Frankensteins monster novel vs the 1931 movie youtube. Character and personality the story of frankenstein written in 1818 by mary shelley and its reenactment in 1931 are two very distinct forms of the same idea. Victor attends the university of ingolstadt, and is unnaturally gifted in chemistry and others sciences. What are the essential differences between the frankenstein novel. Anyone who has read mary shelleys frankenstein and seen james whales 1931 film version knows that the similarities between the two are minuscule at best, while the differences abound. To celebrate the 200th anniversary of mary shelleys gothic masterpiece, frankenstein, we asked film critic and broadcaster, rhianna dhillon to. A comparison of the book and the movie frankenstein. Mary shelley came up with the idea for her masterpiece at a young age, and the book was published in 1818.
Differences between mary shelleys frankenstein book vs movie. Frankenstein the novel is the old testament to i, frankenstein s new. The reanimation of mary shelleys novel mary shelleys novel frankenstein is a cautionary tale of a man named victor frankenstein who plays god and creates a monster that goes on to ruin his life. The events of the novel are in fact pre film, and all covered in the first five minutes. Unlike the previously covered sherlock, this film doesnt so much update to present day as craft a whole new narrative, with many elements completely missing. The context in which a text is placed changes its purpose and allows it to be interpreted in a variety of ways. This movie also spawned several bmovie spinoffs such as the bride of frankenstein, 1935, and son of frankenstein, 1939. The film begins with frankenstein leaving his father and sweetheart to go to school to study the sciences. How is the original frankenstein movie 1931 different from. The film was originally intended as the pilot for an ongoing series, but this was. If you know a difference, dont comment, add it above.
The film tells the story of a doctor augustus phillips who creates a. Whenever there is a movie based on a book, most audiences agree that the book version is better. Horror stories are designed to entertain people by causing enjoyable feelings of horror. Discussion recently i watched an interview with max landis where he said that the final movie of victor frankenstein was about 70% different from his script. From the very beginning, on the stage and as one of the first films ever. One of the most apparent differences between the book and the movie is the actual appearance of the monster. If adam were able to seize upon vlad, adam would tear him apart. Comparison between the film and the book frankenstein 123. In the film, it was assumed that frankenstein made a mistake in the creation. Feb 10, 2014 in which et and haberdasher stand in for reg and hatter to give a books vs. What are the differences between frankenstein the book and.
1375 1539 716 293 347 652 904 1412 118 1443 787 176 213 1322 1327 988 1183 1337 994 1407 913 24 52 1124 279 882 748